Peer Review
- How we review
- From submission to publication
- Decisions
- Confidentiality and conflicts of interest
- Questions and appeals
- Guidelines for reviewers
- Become a reviewer
How we review
Every research and review article in KUJHSS is double-blind peer reviewed: the reviewers don't know who the authors are, and the authors don't know who the reviewers are. Each paper is read by at least two external reviewers who are specialists in its subject. The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision on the basis of their reports.
From submission to publication
- Submission. The author submits through this website, following the Author Guidelines: one anonymised file for the reviewers and one with the title page.
- Editorial check. The editors check that the paper fits the scope, follows the template and is complete. Every paper is checked for similarity with other sources (see Publication Ethics). Papers that don't pass are declined or returned to the author at this stage.
- Publication fee. If the paper passes the editorial check, the editorial office asks the author to pay the publication fee before review begins.
- Peer review. The section editor invites at least two external reviewers. Reviewers accept or decline the invitation within one week and send their report within 30 days. If they disagree, the editor asks a third reviewer.
- Decision. The editor sends the author the decision and the reviewers' comments (see below).
- Revision. The author revises the paper within 30 days, marks every change, and explains in a short reply how each comment was handled. The editor can extend this to 60 days if the author asks. The editor may send the revised paper back to the reviewers.
- Final files. After acceptance, the author prepares the final version in the journal's final (stage-2) template and sends the author details the editorial office asks for.
- Publication. The paper is copy-edited, laid out and checked by the author, then published online with its DOI as soon as it is ready, before the issue closes.
Reviews sometimes take longer than 30 days, for example when the best-qualified reviewers work outside the Kurdistan Region and Iraq. The editorial office keeps the author informed when this happens.
Decisions
- Accept: the paper is accepted as it is.
- Minor revisions: small changes; the editor checks them.
- Major revisions: substantial changes; the revised paper usually goes back to the reviewers.
- Reject: the paper is not suitable for KUJHSS.
Confidentiality and conflicts of interest
- Manuscripts under review are confidential. Editors and reviewers may not share them or use their unpublished ideas or data.
- Reviewers' identities are never revealed to authors.
- Editors and reviewers must declare any conflict of interest with the authors (for example a close colleague, a co-author, a student or a competitor) and step aside from that paper.
- Authors may ask that a named person not review their paper; the editors respect reasonable requests.
- When an editor of KUJHSS submits a paper, another editor handles it, and the author takes no part in any decision on it.
- A paper may not be under review at another journal at the same time.
Questions and appeals
If you think a decision was based on a clear mistake, you can appeal by writing to the Editor-in-Chief at jhss.office@koyauniversity.org within 30 days. Explain the mistake and include your evidence. The Editor-in-Chief, with another editor who was not involved, reviews the appeal; their decision is final.
Guidelines for reviewers
Thank you for reviewing for KUJHSS. Good reviews are fair, specific and constructive: they help the editor decide, and they help the author improve the paper.
Before you accept
- Accept only if the paper is in your field and you can send your report within 30 days. Reply to the invitation within one week.
- Decline if you have a conflict of interest, or if you think you know who the authors are.
What to assess
- Originality and significance: does the paper add something new to its field?
- Fit with the journal: is it within the aims and scope?
- Method: is the approach suitable for the question, and described clearly enough to follow or repeat?
- Evidence and argument: do the conclusions follow from the sources, data or analysis?
- Literature and references: does the paper engage with relevant and recent work, cited correctly in APA style?
- Abstract and title: do they describe the paper accurately, including the English versions?
- Language and structure: is it clear and well organised? Point out problems, but you don't need to correct the language yourself.
- Ethics: tell the editor if you suspect plagiarism, made-up data, or research that needed ethical approval and does not mention it.
Your report
- Complete the journal's review form in the system and recommend a decision: accept, minor revisions, major revisions or reject.
- Write comments for the author that explain your recommendation and say what should change. Be specific and polite. Comments only for the editor go in the confidential field.
- Don't contact the authors directly, and don't share the manuscript or upload it to AI tools or other online services.
Become a reviewer
If you hold a PhD in a field we publish in and would like to review, register on this website and tick Reviewer, with your areas of expertise. You can also write to jhss.office@koyauniversity.org.



