Corrections, Retractions and Appeals

The published record should be accurate and trustworthy. KUJHSS follows the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) on correcting the record, investigating concerns and handling appeals and complaints.

Our approach

  • Published papers are not silently changed or removed. Every change after publication is made through a notice that is published, linked to the paper and given its own DOI.
  • Authors, readers and reviewers can raise a concern by writing to the Editor-in-Chief at jhss.office@koyauniversity.org.
  • We treat every concern confidentially and fairly, and give the authors the chance to respond.

Corrections

When a published paper contains an error that affects its content or understanding (for example a wrong figure, a missing author or a mistake in the data), we publish a correction that says what was wrong and what is right, and we correct the paper itself. Small errors that don't affect the meaning (such as a typo) may be fixed without a notice before the issue is complete.

Authors who find an error in their published paper should tell the editorial office as soon as possible.

Expressions of concern

If there are serious doubts about a paper while an investigation is under way, or the outcome cannot be settled, the editors may publish an expression of concern linked to the paper, to alert readers.

Retractions

A paper is retracted when its findings are unreliable (because of serious error, fabrication or falsification), or when it involves plagiarism, duplicate publication, an undisclosed conflict of interest or a serious ethical problem. The paper stays online, marked "Retracted", with a retraction notice that explains why and who asked for it. Retraction is a decision about the paper, not a judgement on the authors.

Suspected misconduct

When plagiarism, made-up or manipulated data, authorship disputes, citation manipulation or other misconduct is suspected, before or after publication, the editors follow the relevant COPE flowchart: they collect the evidence, ask the authors to explain, and if needed contact the authors' institution. The outcome may be a correction, a retraction, rejection of the paper, or no action.

Appeals against decisions

Authors who believe a decision on their paper was based on a clear mistake (for example a misunderstanding of the paper by a reviewer) may appeal once, within 30 days of the decision. Write to the Editor-in-Chief, explain the mistake and give your evidence. The Editor-in-Chief reviews the appeal with another editor who was not involved in the decision, and may ask a further reviewer. The decision on the appeal is final. A paper under appeal should not be sent to another journal until the appeal is decided.

Complaints

Complaints about how the journal handled a paper, or about its policies or staff, go to the Editor-in-Chief at jhss.office@koyauniversity.org. We acknowledge every complaint within two weeks and reply once it has been looked into. If you are not satisfied with the answer, you can contact COPE.

See also: Publication Ethics and Peer Review.